Fifth Circuit – No Ponzi Clawback From Golf Channel
Janvey v. Golf Channel, Inc., No. 13-11305, 2016 U.S. App. LEXIS 15407 (5th Cir. Aug. 22, 2016)
Stanford International Bank, Ltd. paid $5.9 million to The Golf Channel, Inc., in exchange for a range of advertising services aimed at recruiting additional investors into Stanford’s multi-billion dollar Ponzi scheme. After the scheme was uncovered by the SEC and the District Court seized Stanford’s assets, the court-appointed receiver filed suit under the Texas Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (TUFTA) to recover the $5.9 million paid to Golf Channel. The District Court granted Golf Channel’s motion for summary judgment, having determined that although Stanford’s payments were fraudulent transfers under TUFTA, Tex. Bus. & Com. Code §24.005(a)(1), Golf Channel had established the affirmative defense that it received the payments in good faith and for a reasonably equivalent value.
The Fifth Circuit initially reversed the District Court’s judgment, reasoning based on the text of TUFTA, Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (UFTA), and binding precedent that the payments to Golf Channel were not for “value” because Golf Channel’s advertising services could only have depleted the value of the Stanford estate and thus did not benefit Stanford’s creditors. Subsequently, in response to the view in Golf Channel’s petition for rehearing that the Supreme Court of Texas might not share the same reading of TUFTA, the Fifth Circuit vacated its opinion in Golf Channel I and sought guidance from the Supreme Court of Texas. The Supreme Court of Texas instructed that; TUFTA’s “reasonably equivalent value” requirement can be satisfied with evidence that the transferee (1) fully performed under a lawful, arm’s-length contract for fair market value, (2) provided consideration that had objective value at the time of the transaction, and (3) made the exchange in the ordinary course of the transferee’s business. The opinion clarified that the “value” inquiry under TUFTA does not depend on “whether the debtor was operating a Ponzi scheme or a legitimate enterprise,” so long as “the services would have been available to another buyer at market rates” had they not been purchased by the Ponzi scheme.
Applying these principles to the case at bar, the Supreme Court of Texas determined that “Golf Channel’s media-advertising services had objective value and utility from a reasonable creditor’s perspective at the time of the transaction, regardless of Stanford’s financial solvency at the time.” The Court reasoned that “had Stanford not purchased Golf Channel’s television air time, the services would have been available to another buyer at market rates.” Accordingly, the transfer was for “value” as viewed from the reasonable creditor’s perspective, even if the advertising services “only served to deplete Stanford’s assets”. Consequently, in accordance with the guidance from the Supreme Court of Texas, the Fifth Circuit vacated its reversal of the District Court’s finding that refused to allow a clawback of approx. $6 million paid to the Golf Channel Inc. in a Ponzi scheme and affirmed the District Court’s decision.
Seventh Circuit Affirms Ruling in a Telecom Company Bankruptcy Case
Southern District of Indiana, September 22, 2017 – Debtor, a telecommunications retailer paid the Defendant,…Read More
Preference Action Initiated in Plaza Healthcare Centre LLC
March 3, 2016, California – On March 4, 2014 and March 5, 2014, Plaza Healthcare…Read More
Tax Upset Sale is Not Avoidable Under Sec. 548(a)(1)(B)(i) Because the Price Defendant Paid for the Property Constituted Reasonably Equivalent Value
Crespo v. Abijah Tafari Immanuel (In re Crespo), Nos. 14-11629REF, 14-326, 2016 Bankr. LEXIS 2073…Read More
Creditors Sue Billionaire Blavatnik in Trial Over Lyondell Bankruptcy
New York, October 17, 2016 – Almost a decade after the ill-fated deal that created…Read More
Bankruptcy Clawback Lawsuits Over College Tuition Fees
April 20, 2016, Connecticut – Increasingly, many bankruptcy trustees are starting to sue universities in…Read More