Delaware Bankruptcy Court – Affirmative defenses are not grounds to dismiss the action under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12.
Delaware, September 21, 2017 – Before the Court was the Defendant’s motion to dismiss the complaint of Gavin Solmonese, LLC (the “Liquidating Trustee”) seeking the avoidance and recovery of a preferential transfer. The Defendant asserted the defenses found in sections 547(c)(2)(A) and 547(c)(2)(B) of the Bankruptcy Code as grounds for dismissal. The Trustee opposed that sections 547(c)(2)(A) and 547(c)(2)(B) are not the basis for dismissal. The Court agreed with the Trustee and found that the Trustee’s complaint gives a “short and plain statement” of facts which gave rise to a plausible claim, satisfying both Rule 8 and Rule 12. The Court stated that while deciding whether to dismiss a complaint, the Court does not consider affirmative defenses. Rather, the Court examines the complaint to determine if it appears beyond doubt that the plaintiff can prove no set of facts in support of its claim which would entitle it to relief. Since, the Trustee’s complaint sufficiently alleged that the Debtors transferred a check to the Defendant on May 22, 2015, in the amount of $35,400 which was within the preference period for the Debtors’ case; the Court concluded that this allegation was sufficient to allege a preferential transfer. The Defendant’s motion to dismiss was denied.
Gavin Solmonese, LLC v. True Line Wire (In re Boomerang Sys.), Nos. 15-11729 (MFW), 17-50549 (MFW), 2017 Bankr. LEXIS 3201 (U.S. Bankr. D. Del. Sep. 21, 2017)
Quantum Foods – Opportunity For Leave to Amend a Complaint be Freely Given
Official Comm. of Unsecured Creditors of Quantum Foods, LLC v. Indep. Purchasing Coop., Inc. (In…Read More
A Trustee Avoids Defendant’s Lien on Property as a Preferential Transfer – Time Requirement Under § 547(e)(2) Bars a Defendant From Asserting a Defense Under § 547(c)
December 21, 2017, Ohio — Debtor Richard Asheford purchased a 2011 vehicle from a person…Read More
A New York Court Rejects Merkin’s Attempt to Avoid Trial in the Madoff Clawback
January 30, 2017, New York – In a clawback war between Madoff Trustee, Irving Picard…Read More
State Court Judgment Recorded After Filing of the Bankruptcy is Not a Transfer Under §547(b)(4)
Gallinghouse & Assocs., Inc. v. Black (In re Black), Nos. 15-11935, 15-1071, 15-1073, 2016 Bankr….Read More
Trustee Avoids the Transfer as Preference As the Debtor was Insolvent at the Time the Alleged Transfers Were Made
Lanik v. Smith (In re Cox Motor Express of Greensboro, Inc.), Nos. 14-10468, 15-02023, 2017…Read More